In a famous psychology experiment, dogs were kept in cages and given electric shocks. After a while, the door was left open, and they could have escaped easily. But most didn’t. They had learned that trying was useless. Even when freedom was possible, they stayed put. Psychologists called this learned helplessness.
And that’s not just about dogs; it’s about us.
In India, I see this same story not in a lab but in our homes. While my experience is rooted here, this pattern of learned helplessness is sadly universal, appearing wherever social structures prioritize hierarchy over autonomy. Children in their twenties and thirties still ask their parents for permission before taking a trip, choosing a career, or marrying someone. When parents finally say "yes," everyone smiles proudly and calls it freedom.
But that’s not freedom. It’s permission disguised as freedom.
For generations, we have been conditioned to believe that obedience is a virtue and that permission is a form of love. We know from psychological research how people obey authority, even when it means hurting others, and how humans conform to wrong answers just to fit in. The mind adapts to control until it forgets what real choice feels like. When you are finally allowed to do something after years of restriction, it feels like liberation. Just like those dogs in the experiment, the cage may be open, but the mind still sits inside.
Look at our society. Women are praised when they're “allowed” to work or to remove their ghunghat. Husbands and in-laws proudly say, “We let her do it.” Families call it progress. But if your freedom depends on someone's permission, it isn't freedom—it’s compliance that feels pleasant.
I’ve felt this personally. I never wait for permission. I do what I feel is right. If I want to start something, I just start. If I want to travel, I go. My parents often see it as disobedience or disrespect. They think I'm rebelling against them. Maybe in their world, I am. But in mine, I’m just living.
When you try to change the pattern, you face it all: guilt, judgment, and silence. I’ve faced it all. But I'd rather face that discomfort than live safely inside someone else’s expectations.
Even my friends ask, “Did your parents allow you?” I ask back, “Why does it even matter?” They don’t see the problem, but there is so much wrong with that question. The moment you feel the need to ask, your freedom is already gone.
However, let’s be clear: seeking permission is not the same as asking for advice. When you ask for advice, you are consulting a valuable source of wisdom or perspective, but the power of the final choice rests with you. When you ask for permission, you are handing over the power of choice entirely, making the other person’s "yes" or "no" the final verdict. Adulthood means knowing the difference between consultation and compliance.
This conditioning doesn’t end with parents. Even partners today say, “You should have asked me before deciding.” Society calls it respect. Families call it values. For those enforcing it, this behavior often stems from a genuine, yet misguided, belief in protection or mutual responsibility. But for the receiver, it's often just control dressed as care. These are rules made by those who could make them—not divine, not mutual, just convenient.
This is how conditioning works: First, you're told what's right. Then, you're told what’s allowed. And slowly, you stop deciding for yourself. Until one day, a tiny "yes" feels like a revolution.
But here’s the truth: freedom doesn't come from being allowed. It comes from not needing to ask.
So if you’re an adult—earning, capable, and independent—yet still seeking permission for personal choices like marriage, career, or travel, you aren't truly grown up yet.
I would say: First grow up. Then plan your marriage. Then plan your trip. Then plan your life.
Because freedom doesn't wait for approval. It begins the moment you stop asking for it.
No comments